5 False Discoveries of Extraterrestrials in History

HomeHistory5 False Discoveries of Extraterrestrials in History
Share Button

Mankind has been searching the universe for signs of alien life for more than half a century. So far, the search has yielded no sign of ET. Yet there has been much debate in the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) community about the protocols to follow if — or perhaps when — contact is made. How should the discovery be announced? Would the public react with panic, wonder, or an apathetic shrug of the shoulders? Of course, many feel that this has already happened, and that the government has covered it up. Given the international collaborative nature of modern science, this is highly unlikely. Still, it’s revealing to look at some past moments in history when we thought that alien life had been discovered, if only to see how we reacted at the time.

5. The “Moon Men” Hoax

A hoax in 1835 convinced many that a race of man bats lived on the Moon.

An 1835 lithograph published in The Sun showing civilization on the Moon.

In 1834, astronomer John Herschel journeyed to South Africa to set up an observatory to study the Southern Hemisphere sky. The next year, an upstart New York newspaper eager to increase circulation, The Sun, published a series of articles sensationalizing Herschel’s discoveries. The articles claimed the astronomer had sighted a race of “bat-men” on the Moon, with the creatures living in cities and temples made of sapphire. Rival newspaper editors frantically pursued the story, convinced they’d been scooped. Perhaps the tale wasn’t a stretch for some, as Herschel and many other prominent individuals at the time had professed belief of extraterrestrial life in the solar system. And the population at large seemed to believe the fantastic tale; one religious group even vowed to send missionaries to the Moon to “convert” the batmen. Several weeks later, as scientists began pressing the paper for more details, and rival newspapers started making up their own stories about the man-bats, The Sun confessed to the hoax.


4. Martian Canals

The theory of Martian canals led many people to take for granted that Mars had a civilization.

An 1888 map of supposed Martian canals.

It seems hard to believe today, but mankind took it for granted in the late 19th and early 20th centuries that Mars was inhabited, thanks to the supposed observation of canals on the planet’s surface. In particular, astronomer Percival Lowell observed Mars at every opportunity, sketching and drawing extensive maps of the Red Planet. Lowell painted a portrait of Mars as a dying world, inhabited by a race that had built an extensive system of water works to preserve a precious resource. Keep in mind, in Lowell’s time, an astronomer still held a vigil at an eyepiece and hurriedly sketched fleeting detail during moments of good “seeing.” After Lowell’s death in 1916, astronomers agreed the concept of canals had been an optical illusion. Still, Lowell’s visions of Mars inspired some classic science fiction tales, including H.G. Wells’ War of the Worlds and Ray Bradbury’s The Martian Chronicles. The general acceptance of Martian life probably also explains the hysteria that gripped the population during Orson Wells’ infamous War of the Worlds broadcast in 1938. The theory that Mars might at least support a desert-like environment persisted right up to the first flyby of Mariner 4 in 1965.


3. The Discovery of Pulsars and “Little Green Men”

The discovery of the first pulsar in 1967 led to a brief thought that we had found extraterrestrial life.

Artist’s conception of a pulsar; NASA/JPL-Caltech

In 1967, astronomers Antony Hewish and Jocelyn Bell were surprised to encounter a radio source in the Crab Nebula that pulsated every 1.33 seconds. At that time, no natural source with such precision was known; the team even designated the source as “LGM-1,” for Little Green Men. Had evidence of an extraterrestrial civilization been discovered? One could easily imagine such a source as a sort of cosmic beacon, guiding and synchronizing a space-faring civilization or perhaps telling them to avoid some hazard. The source was later identified as something almost as bizarre — a pulsar, or the remnant of a neutron star’s supernova explosion. Such an object is terrifically dense and about the size of a city, swiftly rotating and spewing energy from its poles. Some 1,800 pulsars have since been discovered. Several years after the discovery of that first pulsar, Bell noted that she did not seriously believe she’d found an alien signal, but that the concept raised some intriguing questions: “It is an interesting problem — if one thinks one may have detected life elsewhere in the universe, how does one announce the results responsibly? Who does one tell first?”


2. The “Wow!” Signal

A strange signal detected in 1977 continues to puzzle astronomers.

A reproduction of the original computer printout of the Wow! signal.

Modern SETI searches began in 1960 with Project Ozma. One of the most interesting finds thus far occurred in 1977, when a research project based at Ohio State University received a 72-second signal over 30 times the intensity of the background noise coming from the constellation Sagittarius. Researcher Jerry R. Ehman wrote “Wow!” in the margins of the printout, and the name stuck. Terrestrial interference is unlikely, as the signal rose and faded as the array rotated along with the Earth, just as a space-based source would. No stars or sources exist near the location, and further attempts to locate the source have come up empty. Was the Wow! signal a brief focusing of an extraterrestrial signal, perhaps gravitationally lensed by a dark, intervening object? Here’s a link to Dr. Ehman’s theories and further searches for the Wow! signal’s source.


1. The Viking Spacecraft “Discovers” Life on Mars

Scientists still disagree about whether or not a Viking probe to Mars in 1976 discovered primitive life.

Images sent from Viking 2 on the surface of Mars in 1976; NASA.

In 1976, NASA’s two Viking spacecraft made the first successful landings on the planet Mars. Both contained an experiment designed to look for microbial life on the Red Planet. Tantalizingly, something in the soil seemed to “interact” with the chemicals in the experiment, just as life might in the process of metabolism. Many chalked this up to a geological process. Most scientists remain unconvinced, however, and the results of the Viking experiments are still hotly contested. Those results are still being studied — a report issued in April 2012 by a former NASA employee and neurobiologist found evidence consistent with life. Even the discovery of primitive life on Mars past or present would have huge implications, as it would mean that life must be fairly common in the cosmos. NASA’s Mars Rover Curiosity is set to land on the Red Planet in early August 2012 and will attempt to follow up on the Viking surface chemistry experiments with an experiment known as SAM, or the Sample Analysis at Mars.


One More: Hoax Touts Life on Martian Moons

On April Fool’s Day 1959, astronomer Walter Scott Houston claimed that the tiny moons of Mars were in fact artificial satellites, hollowed out and constructed by Martians. Though done as a prank, the “theory” was hypothesized in earnest by Soviet astrophysicist Iosif Shklovsky. The idea that many people seemed to take for granted that we shared our solar system with another intelligent species seems to suggest that if — or when — the initial discovery of extraterrestrial life breaks today, it’ll be business as usual. SETI researcher Seth Shostak raises the possibility that even if we detect an extraterrestrial signal, it may be years before we know very much about the other civilization. Of course, if they intend to meddle in our affairs, or land with their death rays blazing on the White House lawn, it might be another story.


If you liked this story, you might like:

12 Reasons We Haven’t Found Extraterrestrials


Written by

David Dickinson is a backyard astronomer, science educator and retired military veteran. He lives in Hudson, Fla., with his wife, Myscha, and their dog, Maggie. He blogs about astronomy, science and science fiction at www.astroguyz.com.